I adored s1 and though s2 was pretty good and s3 is slowly getting there, they won't be the same. I mean the Pilot? Faith? Devil's Trap? They were beyond awesome.

"Hot guys" for the women but "cool enough" that male viewers wished they were the hunters.

definately the way it plays out with the guys I know. Starts off they watch because I've been bugging them for months, then they like the car, and the girl of the week and general seem to fanboy Dean :D